[Desktop_architects] Most wanted Application: Email
Bryce Harrington
bryce at osdl.org
Wed Dec 21 17:15:26 PST 2005
On Wed, Dec 21, 2005 at 05:35:31PM -0500, Mike Shaver wrote:
> On 21-Dec-05, at 4:58 PM, Timothy D. Witham wrote:
> > 2) Group calendaring including meeting scheduling.
> > i..e. I want to check if Tom, Bill, Linus and Buddy the
> > wonder
> > dog are available at 10:00 PM.
> > This includes a laptop resyncing when it gets back to a
> > connected state and the last know schedule being
> > available on a server.
>
> That's not email, but OK, I definitely believe that it's a barrier to
> adoption. Evo has that capability with Exchange now, though -- what
> are the cases in which that breaks down?
> > This seems to be the problem as folks keep doing new clients
> >when the
> >issues is the server side stuff.
>
> I don't understand -- Linux desktop deployment is gated by there not
> being open source servers on Linux for mail and calendaring? Why are
> those related? The Linux desktop could deploy against Exchange/
> GroupWise/Notes/etc., no?
>
> Thanks for the list, though -- what's the source of those pain
> points? From the comments in the survey?
We've heard this from several sources over the years. I also did an
evaluation of calendar/email systems a few years back. I know there's
been a good deal of work in this area, so this report is fairly dated,
but I don't think it's considered a solved problem quite yet...
http://www.osdl.org/projects/cmptblclndrng/results/
I should add that we've considered starting a project to help address
the remaining issues, but our take is that the remaining issues are
_quite hard_ to solve, and at the time it wasn't clear which of the
existing calendaring efforts were worth focusing on.
We ended up going with a non-OSS calendaring server called Synchronize.
We didn't want to go with Exchange/GroupWise/Notes due to cost, Linux
compatibility, and other reasons, however I'd imagine other
organizations wouldn't be quite as gated by the desire for all-OSS
solutions and might find their cost acceptable.
Bryce
More information about the Desktop_architects
mailing list